In other words, aquinas took what aristotle espoused in his metaphysics and discussed it in great detail. Thomas aquinass justly renowned commentary, written at the peak of his scholarly life, illuminates what is obscure in aristotle s text. Pdf aristotles metaphysics in peter auriols commentary. Marc cohen in the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Its influence on the greeks, the muslim philosophers, the scholastic philosophers and even writers such as dante, was immense. Some remarks on averroes long commentary on the metaphysics. Ross book viii part 1 we must reckon up the results arising from what has been said, and compute the sum of them, and put the finishing touch to our inquiry. First, this is not articulated as an explicit argument. Thomas aquinas commentary on aristotles metaphysics. Jan 01, 2007 syrianus attacked aristotle in his commentary on books and 14 of the metaphysics, just as his pupil proclus was to do later in his commentaries on plato. Metaphysics entry by joe sachs in the internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first. For example, listen to aristotle in book i, chapter 9 of the metaphysics. The commentary is replete with helpful references to various parts of aristotle s corpus, especially other books of metaphysics most frequently delta. The internet classics archive metaphysics by aristotle. Ibn sinas metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
The aristotle s metaphysics community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and. This is the only commentary on aristotle s theological work, metaphysics, book 12, to survive from the first six centuries ce the heyday of ancient greek commentary on aristotle. Things that have an essence are those whose account is a definition. Alexander of aphrodisias and the text of aristotles. Headers on each page identify the chapter under consideration. It was thomas aquinas who first judged it to have been abstracted from procluss elements of theology, presumably by an unknown arabic author, who added to it ideas of his own the book of causes is of particular interest because themes. Book gamma asserts that philosophy, especially metaphysics, is the study of being qua being.
The posterior analytics is the summit of aristotle s achievement in logic. A quantitative study of explicit citations to the metaphysics in the rome edition of peter auriols sentences commentary 1617 and toulouse for book i, 1718 and paris for books iiiv. In chapter 8 aristotle states that although a form precedes and produces something, a form itself cannot be produced. In chapter 4 aristotle says, each thing has its proper matter. Aristotle s view on soul, pontiality, actuality, and the possibility o. Alexander composed several commentaries on the works of aristotle, in which he sought to escape a syncretistic tendency and to recover the pure doctrines of aristotle. It is essentially a reconciliation of platos theory of forms that aristotle acquired at the academy in athens, with the view of the world given by common sense and the observations. A bronze sphere, aristotle says, is produced by the sphereform the formal cause and the bronze itself the material cause, so it is the composite formmatter object that is produced, not the form itself.
Read download commentary on aristotles metaphysics pdf pdf. Though the greek text itself is lost, a full english translation is presented here for the first time, based on arabic versions of the greek and a hebrew version of the arabic. Laura castellis commentary has the merit of filling an important gap in aristotelian scholarship, offering an analysis which appeals both to the philosopher and to the historian of philosophy. This concept is known as aristotle s theory of substantial forms. A summary of part x section4 in s aristotle 384322 b. Metaphysics by aristotle book viii classical wisdom weekly. Lecture three in the study of aristotle for students of the school of forbidden texts. Metaphysics aristotle project gutenberg selfpublishing. The annenberg cpbproject provided support for entering this text. He then gives an example of a man to illustrate how a causal explanation can. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first philosophy and assesses possible solutions to. Unlike the dialogues of plato, none of aristotles surviving works are noted for their literary.
Considering the principles of sensible substances 16811767 book 8 as it is divided. It examines what can be asserted about anything that exists just because of its existence and not because of any special. A substantial philosophical commentary guides the reader through the work. May 25, 2012 aristotle collects a list of ten basic categories. Aristotle s metaphysics is foundational for the philosophical study of those speculative objects that extend beyond the realm of natural science. Aristotle himself provides no answers to the puzzles but rather takes them as examples of extreme positions between which he will try to mediate throughout the rest of the metaphysics.
Aristotle notes parenthetically another important aspect of his theory of substance. Humanities metaphysics, epistemology, moral psychology, aesthetics, and the utopian project of the west. It is often contrasted with platos theory of forms. This is because in metaphysics 14, aristotle himself was being thoroughly pol syrianus, originally from alexandria, moved to athens and became the head of the academy there after the. Metaphysics full audio book by aristotle 384 bc 322 bc metaphysics is essentially a reconciliation of platos theory of forms that aristotle acquired at. The metaphysics is considered to be one of the greatest philosophical works. The book of causes, highly influential in the medieval university, was commonly but incorrectly understood to be the completion of aristotle s metaphysics. Aug 15, 1991 this volume contains a close translation, suitable for students without a knowledge of greek, of the seventh and eighth books of aristotle s metaphysics, together with a thorough and careful philosophical commentary. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of aristotle 384322 b. A commentary on book alpha elatton of aristotles metaphysics.
This is because in metaphysics 14, aristotle himself was being thoroughly polemical towards platonism, in particular against the academic doctrine of formnumbers and the whole concept. This superb volume is an indispensible resource for scholars who want to know how aristotle s metaphysics entered western culture and how it fared from the middle ages into the renaissance. Oct, 2017 aristotle s cosmo metaphysics, i propose, finds a close parallel in the metaphysical system represented in the laozi, the daoist classic, and the great commentary on the yijing the book of changes. Since thomas is philosophically convinced that the essence or quiddity of a natural substance includes both matter and form, he seems to have concluded that aristotle himself must have held the same view. The tenth book iota is by far one of the least studied, and commented upon, of aristotle s metaphysics. It is necessary, then, to argue from the points which have been made, and after making a summary, to bring our investigations to a close. This volume includes the complete text of m and n along with 170 pages of commentary that provide a. Lambda as book xii, we could date aquinas commentary after. In chapter 8 aristotle states that although a form precedes and produces something, a. Commentary on aristotles metaphysics aristotelian commentary. Stefan grossmann aristotle s metaphysics a commentary vol.
It has been stated that it is the causes, principles and elements of substances which are being sought 564. The first book of aristotle s metaphysics is attributed. References in the text to the books of aristotles metaphysics are given by greek. A commentary on book alpha elatton of aristotle s metaphysics 4 thinking allows for a true development in the historical evolution of thought and the possibility of the fulfilment of our desire to know. This volume presents a commentary on aristotle s metaphysics book 12 by pseudoalexander in a new translation accompanied by explanatory notes, introduction and indexes. Averroes commentary on the metaphysics, in latin, together with the old arabic and new translation based on moerbeke. Metaphysica 1 is one of the principal works of aristotle and the first major work of the branch of philosophy with the same name. This is a new type of commentary to aristotle s key text, entitled metaphysics after his death. Aristotles metaphysics first published sun oct 8, 2000. Aristotle, averroes, metaphysics, long commentary, the book alpha meizon, linguistical aporias, conception. This volume contains the commentaries on three of aristotle s works, those on his on heaven and earth, on generation and corruption and meteorology. Though the greek text itself is lost, a full english translation is presented here for the first time, based on arabic versions of the greek and a hebrew version of. Commentary on the metaphysics by thomas aquinas translated by john p.
Pdf aristotles metaphysics in peter auriols commentary on. Metaphysics by aristotle, part of the internet classics archive. Green street books employment for adults with special needs. A companion to the latin medieval commentaries on aristotles. Book viii part 1 we must reckon up the results arising from what has been said, and compute the sum of them, and put the finishing touch to our inquiry. An indication of this is our esteem for the senses. The substantial thing that makes a building a building and a human a human is the form. An indication of this is the delight we take in our senses. Sensible substances have different kinds of matter. The fifteenpage translation of aristotle s central text on potentiality and actuality paired with some 285 pages of commentary including the introduction strikes a fair balance. Go to previous table of contents book viii, go to next.
The aristotle s metaphysics community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. Few philosophical books have been so influential in the development of western thought as aristotle s metaphysics. That is, while other sciences investigate limited aspects of being. Kotwicks dense, highly technical book the revised version of her doctoral dissertationis an exhaustive philological investigation into all preserved parts of alexander of aphrodisias commentary on the metaphysics as a witness to the transmission and textual history of this work of aristotle s in antiquity. Averroes tafsir and the book alpha meizon arabic metaphysics. One in itself 19201982 in comparison with multitude 19832145 the first principles of being. The commentary on the sophistical refutations is deemed spurious, as is the commentary on the. The book s uniqueness lies in its aim of letting aquinas himself speak on the subject of metaphysics. Commentary on metaphysics books 16 latinenglish opera. Laura castellis commentary has the merit of filling an important gap in aristotelian scholarship, offering an analysis which appeals both to the. Aristotle notes metaphysics mesa community college.
The work embraces both a history of philosophy and aristotle s subsequent reasoning toward god as pure act. Syrianus attacked aristotle in his commentary on books and 14 of the metaphysics, just as his pupil proclus was to do later in his commentaries on plato. Ultimately he rejected platos ideas as poetic but empty language. Book 8 as it is divided by potency and act 17681919 book 9. The early books give background information and survey the field. Type of citation by the text and commentary ordering of averroes for books a and a as book ii, books 8 1 as books iiix and book a as book xi2 5 in order to esta blis h which translations auriol u ses and in what man n er, nevertheless, one sh ould not conclud e from this particular mod e of ci ting i distinguished th e type of cita tion. The principal subject is being qua being, or being insofar as it is being. In these difficult books, which are central to his metaphysical system, aristotle discusses the nature of perceptible reality. The book is a phrase by phraseparagraph by paragraph commentary written by aquinas on aristotle s actual work.
The twelfth book of aristotle s metaphysics, metaphysics lambda, is in several respects crucial to our understanding not only of aristotle s entire metaphysical system but of central developments in the subsequent history of metaphysical theology taken as a whole in the first instance, in terms internal to his own metaphysical schema, metaphysics lambda seems to answer the demand for an. Just as being is said in many ways, and substance is primary, so also is essence said in many ways, and. Aquinas commentaries, including his commentary on the metaphysics, do indeed express his personal thought. Aristotle s arguments against this theory were numerous. Aristotle s metaphysics, a philological commentary. Thomas aquinas internet encyclopedia of philosophy.
His extant commentaries are on prior analytics book 1, topics, meteorology, sense and sensibilia, and metaphysics books 15. Wisdom consists in understanding the most general truths of all, which are the fundamental principles and causes that govern everything. Metaphysics, or the parts still in existence, spans fourteen books. It investigates the logical requirements for the most perfect of arguments, the demonstration, which proves a necessary conclusion from necessary premises.
This book will remain timeless in its study of aristotle s objective grasp of reality. That being said, given that thomas sometimes corrects aristotle in these works see, for example, his commentary on physics, book 8, chapter 1, it seems right to say that thomas commentaries on aristotle are usefully consulted to elucidate thomas own views on philosophical topics as well. Commentary on aristotles metaphysics aristotelian commentary series saint thomas aquinas, richard j. We have said that the causes, principles, and elements of substances are. When aristotle died, his library, including all his notes, the rough drafts of his. The zapata times 7192017 by the zapata times issuu.
For centuries aristotle s most celebrated work has been regarded as a source of inspiration as well as the starting point for every investigation into the structure of reality. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first philosophy and assesses possible solutions to them. In the first instance, in terms internal to his own metaphysical schema, metaphysics lambda seems to answer the demand for an inquiry into immaterial substance set by aristotle in the difficult middle books of the metaphysics, an inquiry evidently held to be necessary for the proper understanding of such familiar sensible substances as human. Each chapter of the commentary corresponds to one chapter of theta and begins with an overview of the chapters contents. Castelli presents a new translation and comprehensive commentary of the tenth book iota of aristotles. A complete english edition of a key book from one of the most influential of philosophical works. Stephen makin has produced an interesting and demanding contribution to the clarendon aristotle series. M and n, the last two books of the metaphysics, are aristotle s only sustained venture into the philosophy of mathematics. Pdf aquinass commentary on the metaphysics gabriele. With a view to the science under investigation we must attack first those subjects which must first be investigated.
Book by book analysis book i a, alpha, 980a993a first causes and principles 1 knowledge of sensation is to science. These are all the subjects about which some men have entertained different opinions, and any other besides these which has been omitted. In three volumes, burning modern issues are worked in, revealing the lost ancient meaning as a meditation text of inner alchemy the middle books and logical cosmology the late books. On the one hand, aristotle explicitly says throughout the central books that form is the essence of sensible substances35. Arthur madigan presents a clear, accurate new translation of the third book beta of aristotle s metaphysics, together with two related chapters from the eleventh book kappa. Thomass view of the celestial bodies while on generation and corruption presents aristotle s thought on the coming to be and passing away of substances. An element is that into which a thing is divided and which is present in it as matter, e.
16 1548 901 809 1431 1129 806 972 681 1115 222 42 1548 84 913 1325 1270 1694 1142 621 1163 633 771 522 1053 1229 820 350 70 1598 1450 437 1441